Question regarding flat wound strings

The original shortscale guitars; Mustangs, Duo-Sonics, Musicmasters, Jaguars, Broncos, Jag-stang, Jagmaster, Super-Sonic, Cyclone, and Toronados.

Moderator: mods

User avatar
GreenKnee
.
.
Posts: 644
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2009 5:23 pm
Location: Sheffield

Question regarding flat wound strings

Post: # 1393978Post GreenKnee »

Photo of D'Addario Chrome Low E

I've been using D'Addario Chromes for a couple of years on my Jaguars, but I have recently purchased some Thomastik JS110 to try out for a change after hearing great things about them. I'm a little concerned as I have read that they can be quite fragile when restringing due to their round core as opposed to a hexagonal core. They come with silk wrapped round the end of the windings in order to keep the winding to the core, but on the Jaguar the string has to be cut down to length short of this silk starting. As you can see from the attached photo, the Chromes that are currently on my Jag have split at the tuner, but the string still holds itself together fine. I'm concerned about this with the Thomastiks as this might cause them to break. Any guidance would be greatly appreciated, thanks


And as a bonus as I haven't posted for a while, here is a pic of my current Jaguars:

Left - right:
Late 90's CIJ (this one I keep tuned to drop C#) with AVRI Jaguar pickups
1962 Jaguar, refinished in Olympic White some time in its past,and I've just had it refretted due to ugly jumbos, but other than that it is stock.
2018 American Original Jaguar - all stock

I DON'T KNOW HOW TO POST PHOTOS ANYMORE /ROBROE
User avatar
robroe
Bon Jovi Fan Club!!1
Posts: 49936
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 1:00 pm

Post: # 1394023Post robroe »

ive been using Chromes for 15 years now. they routinely do what you have photoed when winding on a slot head tuner.

not sure about this new brand.


how much do they cost ?

if you are only out 10 bucks give it a go. not the end of the world.


if they are like 30 bucks a set they can get fucked anyways. hahahaha


the nice thing about Chromes is you never have to replace them, they never sound worn out, because they sound worn out the first time you string them up. I've got some guitars with the same strings on there for over 10 years.
dots wrote:incesticide
User avatar
GreenKnee
.
.
Posts: 644
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2009 5:23 pm
Location: Sheffield

Post: # 1394034Post GreenKnee »

Bloody hell 10 years is impressive! The new set is only a few quid more than the Chromes, so I'll just go at it I think
I've never been unsatisfied with the chromes to be honest, so I don't know why I'm fretting about it so much. Thanks for the inspiration to not worry about it too much
User avatar
GreenKnee
.
.
Posts: 644
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2009 5:23 pm
Location: Sheffield

Post: # 1395572Post GreenKnee »

FYI Chromes are way smoother than the fancy Thomastik, the chromes make thomastik feel like something in-between round and flat
User avatar
paul_
.
.
Posts: 10117
Joined: Thu Jul 27, 2006 10:38 pm

Post: # 1395785Post paul_ »

GreenKnee wrote:Bloody hell 10 years is impressive!
I have two basses that both have the first flatwound sets I put on them when I got them in 2003 and 2010. They last forever if you need them to.

I use Fenders for bass, could never personally get on with flats for guitar though, I tried Chromes 11s on an SG once.
Aug wrote:which one of you bastards sent me an ebay question asking if you can get teh kurdtz with that 64 mustang? :x
robertOG wrote:fran & paul are some of the original gangstas of the JS days when you'd have to say "phuck"
User avatar
NickD
.
.
Posts: 4882
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 7:41 am
Location: Sheffield, Innit

Post: # 1395804Post NickD »

paul_ wrote:
GreenKnee wrote:Bloody hell 10 years is impressive!
I have two basses that both have the first flatwound sets I put on them when I got them in 2003 and 2010. They last forever if you need them to.

I use Fenders for bass, could never personally get on with flats for guitar though, I tried Chromes 11s on an SG once.
I found they were great if you aren't bending notes, but a pain if you are. I only have a couple of electrics now so I can't have a guitar with that narrow a use.
User avatar
plopswagon
.
.
Posts: 14313
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2007 3:32 pm
Location: Behind you. Don't turn around
Contact:

Post: # 1395806Post plopswagon »

Donald “Duck� Dunn, the bass player for Booker T and the MG’s, allegedly used the same flatwounds for the majority of his career.
theshadowofseattle wrote:Happy birthday dot
Hurb wrote: Fri Oct 29, 2021 11:31 amIts like Mumford and Sons never happened.
Image
mondaysoutar
.
.
Posts: 2
Joined: Wed Jul 01, 2020 6:10 pm

Post: # 1397626Post mondaysoutar »

hi, Im wondering if when going over to flat wound strings you have to adjust the truss rod? Its an American Original Jazzmaster I'm considering putting them onto, obviously not short scale, but hopefully cool for me to get involved! I only got the guitar the middle of last year and went for gauge 11 pure nickel D'Addarios. It would either be Chromes or Thomastik's in the same gauge I'd go to.

I had a CIJ Jag and had thomastik flats on it, but it was years and years ago, so can't quite remember if I had to tweak the truss or not.

Im new here, so hopefully its cool for me to ask away, etc.
User avatar
robroe
Bon Jovi Fan Club!!1
Posts: 49936
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 1:00 pm

Post: # 1397628Post robroe »

No adjustment needed. You all good.
dots wrote:incesticide
mondaysoutar
.
.
Posts: 2
Joined: Wed Jul 01, 2020 6:10 pm

Post: # 1397640Post mondaysoutar »

ah thanks Robroe, appreciate it.
User avatar
kim
[='±'=]
Posts: 12514
Joined: Tue May 30, 2006 8:30 am
Location: BE

Post: # 1404696Post kim »

Got a few sets of Thomastik Jazz Swings on the way (12's and 11's) to try out.

I read you could give them a knick/sharp bend before the cut to secure the core before you cut off the ends.
Like with pliers or something, fold/press them...but i need them to arrive to see if it can be done on the heavier gauges and they still fit in the split kluson style posts, probably not an issue.

Might make a post when i'm changing to a set.
User avatar
dezb1
The Oppressor
Posts: 7973
Joined: Sun Mar 01, 2009 3:59 am
Location: glasgow
Contact:

Post: # 1404697Post dezb1 »

I bought a set to try out a few weeks ago stoll to get them on a guitar.
Image
User avatar
NickD
.
.
Posts: 4882
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 7:41 am
Location: Sheffield, Innit

Post: # 1404728Post NickD »

NickD wrote:
paul_ wrote:
GreenKnee wrote:Bloody hell 10 years is impressive!
I have two basses that both have the first flatwound sets I put on them when I got them in 2003 and 2010. They last forever if you need them to.

I use Fenders for bass, could never personally get on with flats for guitar though, I tried Chromes 11s on an SG once.
I found they were great if you aren't bending notes, but a pain if you are. I only have a couple of electrics now so I can't have a guitar with that narrow a use.
To completely contradict myself, I have had flatwounds on my Jazzmaster for a couple of months now and I'm enjoying them on there, especially for legato playing.
User avatar
Hurb
Peanut the Kidnapper
Posts: 6766
Joined: Mon Apr 17, 2006 8:47 pm

Post: # 1404732Post Hurb »

I have some 13 flatwounds coming for my Jag too. Never used the. Before so interested in how I get on with them
User avatar
Noirie.
YOUTH
Posts: 5338
Joined: Thu Jan 15, 2009 9:51 pm

Post: # 1404733Post Noirie. »

I’ve got a set of .011 D’addario flats on my Jaguar atm. Tuned to E flat and no issues with tryna play leads. Only feel slightly heavier than a normal set.

Tried .013s on it years ago and the low E from that set broke the nut.
theshadowofseattle wrote:less being WOKE
more being STOKED
User avatar
robroe
Bon Jovi Fan Club!!1
Posts: 49936
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 1:00 pm

Post: # 1404858Post robroe »

Noirie. wrote:I’ve got a set of .011 D’addario flats on my Jaguar atm. Tuned to E flat and no issues with tryna play leads. Only feel slightly heavier than a normal set.

Tried .013s on it years ago and the low E from that set broke the nut.

did you file it out a little first or were you just like fuck it let the string grind the shit out of it and make its own hole?


(ive done both)
dots wrote:incesticide
User avatar
kim
[='±'=]
Posts: 12514
Joined: Tue May 30, 2006 8:30 am
Location: BE

Post: # 1404873Post kim »

Odd, had a 62 gauge string for a while on my mustang and Knurdtz jag and no nut issues (tuned to B standard). My Ernie ball Mammoth phase...
120 gauge on my p bass now. Tuned to D standard but going back to 110 soon.

Was just experimenting with b standard tuning but back to e standard now.

I put thomastik jazz swing 12-50 on my classic vibe jazzmaster.
I thought they were the 11-47 set I got... I only realized about 30mins after playing I put on the 'wrong' set (got 12s for my KC jag).

Went from factory 9s (bah) to 10-46s (OK..low E too thin) and now a big jump to 12-50s but I like. Can really dig in. The top strings need a bit more power in chording.

The lighter gauge strings felt like 'wow this is effortlessl!' but I couldn't dig in and though chording was 'easier', less room for error in finger position. Just because it was so 'effortless'.
User avatar
Hurb
Peanut the Kidnapper
Posts: 6766
Joined: Mon Apr 17, 2006 8:47 pm

Post: # 1404954Post Hurb »

Perhaps its because its a new thing that cost 18 quid...but I am loving these new thomastik-infeld flatwounds.
I have never tried flatwounds before so have nothing to compare them to. But everything about them I love.
They are super loud unplugged, this seems to transfer through the pickups too, they certainly don't sound dull. But are more full sounding. The other weird thing is each switch on the jaguar seems to change the sound more noticeably. So the tone cut for example really cuts. I think I have more sustain too. They feel nice. I don't play enough these days to have super hard finger ends so roundwounds hurt. There is enough bite to them though that you have control.

The 13s were under a bit too much tension for me in E standard. So I have dropped down to D. That has sorted tension. 12s would of been ideal.
I really encourage anyone to try them. I did have adust the neck relief I also shimmed a bit more. But I had 10s on beforehand.

I had a slightly buzzy G when played open as the nut probably needs recuting, the wound G has sorted it. No more buzz.

Oh and I haven't stretched the strings like I normally do and tuning is still amazing!
User avatar
Nick
Y'SEE!?
Posts: 8900
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 3:13 am
Location: Albany, NY

Post: # 1404959Post Nick »

I strongly disagree with Rob about truss rod adjustment. In both bass and guitar, flatwounds have increased tension, it might not be obvious at first but over time it will usually bow the neck unless maybe you’re going from a very heavy roundwound to a very light flat wound.

You might not need to adjust at all depending on the individual guitar, but you should keep watch over the neck bow over the next few minutes, hours and days, and make adjustments accordingly in 8th turn increments. A little goes a long way.
User avatar
Hurb
Peanut the Kidnapper
Posts: 6766
Joined: Mon Apr 17, 2006 8:47 pm

Post: # 1404968Post Hurb »

Nick wrote:I strongly disagree with Rob about truss rod adjustment. In both bass and guitar, flatwounds have increased tension, it might not be obvious at first but over time it will usually bow the neck unless maybe you’re going from a very heavy roundwound to a very light flat wound.

You might not need to adjust at all depending on the individual guitar, but you should keep watch over the neck bow over the next few minutes, hours and days, and make adjustments accordingly in 8th turn increments. A little goes a long way.
Yeah 100%
Post Reply